Right-wing movements mobilise support by temporarily stirring anti-refugee and anti-immigrant sentiment with cherry-picked crime stories. The key to make a stable mass movement is to keep the support over time. Echo chambers entrench support over time, and conspiracy theories help construct those echo chambers. Conspiracy theories reason in circles — the source is itself part of the explanation — leaving them without falsifiable external sources, and resistant to fact-checking. They thereby lock hard core supporters into a logical loop and exclude critical voices.
Opinion polls give grounds to suggest that many people believe these undocumented stories: in 2023, 57% of Republicans believed Biden’s 2020 election win was illegitimate. A 2022 Yahoo News/YouGov poll found that 61% of Trump voters in the 2020 election agreed that “a group of people in this country are trying to replace native-born Americans with immigrants and people of colour who share their political views”.
A survey by Politico/Morning Consult poll in 2017 found that ˆMore than three-quarters of Republican voters, 76 percent, think the news media invent stories about Trump and his administration” A 2018 poll by Axios and SurveyMonkey found that 92% of Republicans and Republican-leaning independents believed that traditional news outlets knowingly report false or misleading stories at least sometimes.
The reason to believe that many of those who believe in these claims about media plots trust them firmly. As Trump in 2019 said that news media are “the enemy of the people” 60 % of the voters agreed, and 30 % of these 60 % agreed strongly according to a Rasmussen poll study. An Ipsos study in 2020 found that 39 % of Americans agreed there is a deep state working to undermine President Trump.
The “deep state” conspiracy theory is typical—a hidden network of a secret elite is claimed to secretly run government. Since the alleged plot and the secret elite behind it is hidden, external independent sources are hard to find. You have to choose if you believe it or not, which makes these conspiracy theories ideal as a ideological base for a mass movement of those who distrust the political mainstream and the authorities. Conspiracy theories do not meet the criteria of falsifiability, the possibility to fact check a story defined by Karl Popper.
As opposed to conspiracy theories, real conspiracies exist, and are also by their nature hidden, but they eventually surface through investigation evidence, or leaks. Or they remain hidden, and you will never hear of them. Conspiracy theories can travel very far, and they can exist and circulate for a very long time. This is how you tell a conspiracy theory you have heard from a real conspiracy: if it was real, external, independent sources would eventually confirm it. If a story of a conspiracy has existed over time, and no falsifiable sources ever emerges, you are probably dealing with a conspiracy theory.
The “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” — a conspiracy theory central to Nazi ideology — claims a secret Jewish conspiracy is seeking world power. Proved false in 1920, it has nonetheless circulated for more than 120 years. If there were any evidence for it, it would have surfaced by now.
Keeping core believers inside the bubble
A violent crime committed by a minority, immigrant, or refugee can temporarily inflame hostility toward the entire group. The effect fades over time as other stories — with majority-group perpetrators — push it out of view, and as positive stories about the same minority push back against it. This is a reason for right-wing parties to work to silence critics and to control the mass media.
This can be done by creating epistemic bubbles or echo chambers as alternative to edited mass media for transferring political messages. Echo chambers and epistemic bubbles are primarily defined by leaving out corrective information. An Echo chamber is, as defined by philosopher C. Thi Nguyen, a social epistemic structure that other relevant voices have been actively excluded and discredited from. An epistemic bubble occurs when the critical voices, perhaps accidentally, have been left out. Some also choose to be silent.
Right wing populist politicians often try to discredit counter information by spreading conspiracy theories about edited mass media and fact checks, human rights activists and opposing politicians. Neutralising the free press would also silence any critics of the political and personal conduct of right-wing politicians.
Echo chambers and epistemic bubbles have always existed in conversation in communication between people, and gossip stories are efficient media for transferring meaning. Influencers and social media have made political messages even more potent, reaching vast numbers of people.
The “fake news from the fake news media” conspiracy theory is a circular argument: the news is fake because it comes from the fake news media. With the source built into the argument, no external independent sources exist. It is a closed belief system—you either believe it or you do not. Sharing it creates an echo chamber that excludes critical voices, such as corrections from edited news media. This makes it an ideal ideology for the hard core of believers.
Stories of violent immigrant crime enable right wing supporters to take the moral high ground in informal social fora. When somebody tells such dramatic stories, they can dominate the talk in a social group. The stories told may appear to be non-partisan, but it is important to be aware that spreading stories about violent immigrant crime are an important part of the right wing strategy.
It is also not obvious that you are exposed to propaganda when you hear a story from somebody you trust personally. If such stories are told unopposed, they can make an informal sosial group or a social media group into an epistemic bubble. It is a great advantage for right wing populists if they can seed themes what become discussed in daily talk among people. The discussion in informal groups of people can create epistemic bubbles. When there is absence of critical voices, stories of alleged violent crime can be broadcasted and amplified.
Peer pressure can make you not object when you hear a story. Some researchers have put forward that the conformity in epistemic bubbles are important for making gossip stories and rumours with strong negative biases generally accepted. It is not easy to decide if a new story somebody tells the truth, since you have never heard about it, and the claims are new to you. A natural response could be accepting, like “really, that was chocking”, not asking critical questions.
Epistemic bubbles can be individual, like a political partisan who gets his news only from one sided news sources, dismissing other sources as “Fake News“, or a conspiracy theorist. Some of the lone wolf terrorists have lived in epistemic bubbles created by conspiracy theories on the Internet. Epistemic bubbles can be real world social groups, or social media groups on the internet.
People are more likely to retell stories when the accused perpetrator is an outsider — foreign, unknown, and someone they seldom encounter in social contexts. This illustrates that lack of social contact between different cultures can make a fertile ground for xenophobia and foreign hate. Since the ones in out-category are not present in discussions in majority groups, they can not defend their own reputation.
“Fake News”: A tribal howl
Donald Trump has systematically tried to discredit the mainstream media by commenting by establishing the symbol “Fake News“. The “Fake News” claims that that the undefined “Fake News media” works synchronised to mislead the public. The general claim that editorially controlled media as “Fake News Media” is circular. It builds in the source for the claim as its own evidence. It does therefore not have any external or independent sources. You have to choose if you beilieve it or not.
“Fake News” becomes embedded as a permanent symbol for the in-group. The claims about “Fake News” from “The Fake News Media” circulates widely in the grass root of the MAGA movement, as suggested by two research reports from USA. They have become defining slogans for their subculture, a way for MAGA to distinguish themselves from “Rinos” (moderate republicans) and supporters of other political parties. The slogan signal allegiance the same way as wearing a red MAGA hat would, but less obvious.
The circulation of the “Fake News” and the “Fake News Media” within the MAGA would also construct a perfect echo chamber, where every critical voice and every correction and fact check of the presented stories would be actively dismissed.